Making Maraschino Cherries

Posted by A69143a5 tiny Jen Messier on aug 9, 2013 under Blog Post

I love the bright red cherries that you get at the grocery store for $2. I really, really love them.

But a few summers ago, I made some "real" maraschino cherries using the good stuff: Luxardo Maraschino liqueur, and was blown away by the results. These guys are absolutely nothing like the ones you grew up with: they're boozy, rich, and complex, instead of just sweet and syrupy like the grocery store version. 

The Key Ingredient

image

Make sure you get this bottle! 

To make these, you need maraschino liqueur. It's a traditional Italian liqueur made from sour mascara cherries and their pits. You'll find it's not very sweet and a little bitter. 

The most famous brand, also considered the best tasting, is Luxardo, but it can be a bit tough to track down. In Manhattan, they sell it at Astor Place Wines & Spirits, and in Brooklyn I've always had luck at Heights Chateau on Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn Heights. It'll run you about $28/bottle in the NYC area. 

Luxardo also makes a very expensive jar of maraschino cherries that you can buy at fancy grocery stores. I've spied them at Court Street Grocers, but haven't had the guts to pay the $20 to try them. 

The Recipe

I used a simplified recipe originally drawn from Serious Eats, and it's pretty easy even if you hate cooking. 

image

This is why you buy a cherry pitter.

First, prep 1lb of cherries by washing and pitting them.

I don't have a cherry pitter, and I still haven't found a great workaround, but lately I've been using the handle a plastic fork to dig out the pit. It sometimes destroys the cherry but it usually gets the job done. Other geniuses on the internet suggest using a paper clip, smashing it like garlic, or just plain old using a knife. 

Once they're pitted, throw together in a pot:

1/2 cup sugar
1/2 cup water
squeeze lemon juice
some vanilla extract

When the syrup boils, throw in a the pitted cherries and cook for 5-7 minutes.

Finally, take them off the heat and add 1 cup of the Luxardo Maraschino (or any maraschino liqueur). Let them cool and store them in the refrigerator for up to two weeks. At this point, I also added a couple dashes of meyer lemon bitters, for no other reason than that I had them on hand and there was already some lemon juice in the recipe. 

 

Tagged with ice cream luxardo maraschino liqueur

Related Posts

Comments